United took a 2-0 lead but managed to throw away both the match and a place in the next round. For the first time in half a century, the Red Devils lost a home game after leading by two goals. It was a historic setback that compounded the poor return of just four points from the opening four league matches.

The problem is not merely a matter of statistics. The team still appears fragile, lacking a clear playing identity and the mental resilience demanded by its badge. The new season began with promises of a resurgence, yet the old spectre of instability returned before September was even over.

Carrick remains in his post for the time being, but the match against Fulham is already shaping up to be a make-or-break moment. Another defeat could turn the board's doubts into a definitive decision, prematurely closing a chapter that began with optimism but risks ending in disappointment.

Meanwhile, the search for a successor is already underway behind the scenes. The names of Kieran McKenna and Eddie Howe are being discussed, but the one that stands out is Julian Nagelsmann.

The 39-year-old German—with stints at RB Leipzig, Bayern Munich, and the German national team—is available following his departure from the *Nationalmannschaft*. His age, tactical boldness, and experience managing a massive club make him an attractive option for a United side seeking to regain its direction

For now, Carrick remains at the helm. He knows, however, that in the high-stakes world of football, the gap between retaining confidence and facing the sack can span a mere ninety minutes. And against Fulham, he may well be playing not just for three points, but for his entire future.