The former defensive midfielder's tenure lasted only three games (2 wins, 1 draw). Of course, we must note that at that time the management had no confidence in Carrick since the changes he had made, leaving important stars out of the starting lineup.

Now, after repeated mistakes (Ragknig, De Haag and recently Amorim), the Manchester United management has turned to Carrick again after a four-year cyclical situation. The disappointment has returned, but the situation is now much worse.

The financial legacy, brand and charm that Sir Alex built over decades have probably been eroded by successive generations of Manchester United leaders. In this case, it is very difficult for Manchester United to find a truly great manager. Even their plans to find a replacement are facing difficulties.

In fact, Carrick did not even ask for a long-term contract. “To have the responsibility of leading Manchester United is an honour,” Carrick said. “I know what it takes to succeed here; my focus now is on helping the players reach the standards we demand at this great club, which we know this team is fully capable of delivering,” he added.

In the first Manchester derby of 2026, Carrick led United to a significant 2-0 victory over a weak City at Old Trafford (matchday 22). The ‘Red Devils’ were superior and dominated almost completely, especially in the second half. In fact, with their victory they temporarily climbed to 4th place in the standings (35 points). Their players were amazing and got what they deserved with goals from Mbeumo (65') and Dorgu (76').

Now whether the 45-year-old Carrick will succeed in leading the team back to the steady cycle of successes or if he will fail, we will find out very soon

.